Skip to main content
Fidelity Residential home
For renters thinking of buying

Rent vs buy calculator

Compare the cost of renting with the cost of owning over the years you plan to stay, using your own numbers and your own assumptions about rents, home values and returns. See the equity you could build and the year owning could pull ahead. It runs in your browser and nothing you type is sent to us.

Prefer to talk? Call 732-686-9999

  • Direct, licensed mortgage lender
  • NMLS #103098
  • Equal Housing Lender

More calculators

Get a quote

Ready for the full application? Apply online

Fidelity Residential · NMLS #103098 · Equal Housing Lender

Calculator

Compare renting and buying

Every box starts empty. The answer depends entirely on what you type, including how you expect rents, home values and your savings to change; we make no forecast. Leave a box blank to count it as zero.

Everything here runs in your browser. Nothing you type is sent to us, saved, or added to the page address. See our Privacy Policy.

Buying

From a quote or a lender. This page does not suggest a rate.
The closing costs on your quote, paid in cash when you buy.
Agent commission, transfer taxes and other costs you expect when you sell.

Renting

Your assumptions

From 1 to 40.
Your own guess. Type a minus sign for a fall.
Your own guess. Home values can fall as well as rise; type a minus sign for a fall.
What the down payment and buying costs might earn if you rent and keep the cash instead.

Your estimate

This is an estimate from your own assumptions, not a forecast, an offer or a loan decision.

Cost of owning over your stay – Cost of renting over your stay – – Break-even year – Type the home price, your rent, the years you plan to stay, and the rate and term on your quote to see the comparison.
Owning, from your numbers
Principal and interest, a month–
First month, with tax, insurance, dues and upkeep–
Down payment and buying costs–
Monthly and yearly costs over the stay–
Return given up on the cash–
Cash back from the sale–
Cost of owning–
At the end of your stay
Home value, on your assumption–
Loan balance left–
Equity–
Cash after selling costs and the loan payoff–
Not counted: tax effects, mortgage insurance, renter’s insurance, moving costs, or investing any monthly difference. Tax, insurance, dues and upkeep stay at the figures you type.
Guide

How the comparison is worked out

The cost of renting: every month’s rent over the years you plan to stay, with the rent changing each year by the share you type.

The cost of owning: the down payment and buying costs, every mortgage payment of principal and interest, the property tax, insurance, association dues and upkeep, and the return your cash could have earned if you had kept it. From that total, the calculator takes away the cash you would get back when you sell: the home’s value on your assumption, less the selling costs and the loan balance left.

The break-even year: the first year in which owning has cost less than renting. Buying costs and selling costs weigh most on a short stay, so the longer you stay, the more the comparison tends to move toward owning; but with your numbers it may not.

What it leaves out: tax effects, mortgage insurance, renter’s insurance and moving costs, and what you might do with any monthly difference between rent and the cost of owning. To check a payment on its own, try the payment calculator; to see how a housing payment fits your income, try the debt-to-income ratio calculator.

A worked example, with example figures. Morgan and Riley Example, fictional renters, pay $2,400 a month and look at a home priced at $400,000. Every figure here is an example for you to replace with your own; none is our rate, payment, cost or forecast.

Buying. They would put $40,000 down and borrow $360,000 over 30 years. Principal and interest at the rate on their quote come to $2,275 a month (example figure). Property tax is $6,000 a year, insurance $1,500 and upkeep $4,000, with no association dues. Their quote shows $10,000 of buying costs, and they expect selling costs of 6% of the sale price.

Their assumptions. They plan to stay 7 years, and for this example they assume rent and the home’s value each change by 3% a year and that cash they keep would earn 4% a year. Those are their guesses, not ours.

The result. Over 7 years, renting costs about $220,679 and owning about $200,500, so on these assumptions owning comes out about $20,179 ahead. The break-even year is year 6. At the end, the home would be worth about $491,950 with about $325,498 left on the loan: about $166,451 of equity, or about $136,934 in cash after selling costs.

What moves it. With a 3-year stay, or with home values flat, the same numbers favor renting. Change one assumption at a time to see which matters most to you. Get a quote

Questions

Rent vs buy calculator questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy?

It depends on the price, the rent, how long you stay and how rents, home values and your savings change, so there is no single answer. This calculator compares the two from your own numbers and assumptions; it makes no forecast.

How does a rent vs buy calculator work?

It adds up what renting would cost over your stay and what owning would cost: the down payment, buying costs, mortgage payments, tax, insurance, dues and upkeep, plus the return your cash could have earned. It then takes away the cash you would get back from selling the home, after selling costs and the loan payoff.

What is the break-even year?

The first year in which owning has cost less in total than renting. Before that, buying and selling costs usually outweigh the equity you have built. The calculator checks up to 40 years and tells you if there is no break-even on your numbers.

Why does the return on my cash matter?

Money spent on a down payment and buying costs cannot earn a return elsewhere. Counting that return gives renting credit for the cash a renter keeps. If you would not invest the cash, type nothing and it counts as zero.

Does the calculator include taxes?

It includes property tax, but not income tax effects such as a mortgage interest deduction or tax on a sale, which depend on your own situation. A tax professional can tell you how owning would affect your taxes.

What should I do after running the numbers?

Replace your guesses with real figures where you can: a quote for the rate and closing costs, the tax bill on the home and an insurance quote. Our first-time buyer guide and down payment assistance page explain the next steps.

Is anything I type saved or sent?

No. The calculator runs in your browser. Nothing you type is sent to us, saved, or added to the page address, and closing the page clears it. To talk your numbers through, call 732-686-9999 or start a quote.

Thinking about buying?

Get a quote, apply online, or talk your numbers through with a licensed mortgage specialist.

This page is general information, not a commitment to lend. Programs, terms and eligibility depend on credit, income, property and underwriting review and are subject to change without notice.

Last reviewed: